Carl Schmitt’s State and Constitutional Theory. A Critical Analysis. Benjamin Schupmann. Oxford Constitutional Theory. Explores Carl Schmitt’s response to the. 5 Nov Seitzer, J. and Thornhill, C. () An introduction to Carl Schmitt’s constitutional theory: Issues and context. In: Seitzer, J. (ed.) Carl Schmitt. This book analyzes Carl Schmitt’s state and constitutional theory and shows how he conceived it in response to the Weimar crisis. Schmitt modeled his theory on.

Author: Kenos Muzil
Country: Turkmenistan
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Technology
Published (Last): 22 February 2010
Pages: 369
PDF File Size: 15.76 Mb
ePub File Size: 12.51 Mb
ISBN: 665-5-13613-498-3
Downloads: 56298
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Bragrel

The same holds, Schmitt thinks, for all other substantive distinctions that may become markers of identity and difference. As a result, the positive carl schmitt constitutional theory can at best determine who is to decide whether there is an emergency that requires a wholesale suspension of the law.

At the center of this interpretation lies his famous argument that the legitimacy of a constitution depends on a sovereign decision of the people. The only candidate for sovereignty carl schmitt constitutional theory a democratic polity is the popular sovereign, composed of politically equal citizens.

This view overlooks, Schmitt argues, that general legal norms often fail to provide determinate guidance without considerable interpretation and interstitial legislation PT 29—35; GU 21— It would be impossible for there to be a plurality of political communities — and hence, since political community is only possible where a group has enemies, for there to be any political community — if there were only one legitimate form of social organization or communal life CP 53—8.

Of course, Schmitt’s hopes were disappointed when the war, after catastrophic bloodshed, ended in a stalemate between two hegemonic powers that were both unwilling to repudiate universalist ideology, but nevertheless quite successful in preventing their own conflict carl schmitt constitutional theory escalating carl schmitt constitutional theory open war.

The Hidden DialogueChicago: On the other hand, Schmitt claims that the attempt to subject the use of force on the part of political communities to external legal constraint and control, apart from constituting an assault on the possibility of political existence, will only lead to greater disorder and violence than we can expect to experience in a system that recognizes the political.


Sign-in or register now to continue. Constitutional Theory Carl Carl schmitt constitutional theory Limited preview – Unsurprisingly, the significance and value of Schmitt’s works is subject to heated controversy Caldwell The national socialist movement, in Schmitt’s view, had managed to orchestrate an varl of constituent power and to create a new constitution; one that was willing to draw uncompromising distinctions between the German people and its internal and external enemies.

It does not glorify war, but merely claims that a community that is interested in living politically needs carl schmitt constitutional theory be willing to go to war if it perceives its political existence to be threatened CP 32—5.

Legal norms, Schmitt argues, cannot be applied to a chaos.

Carl Schmitt’s State and Constitutional Theory – Benjamin Schupmann – Oxford University Press

To purchase, visit your preferred ebook provider. Carl Schmitt and the Rechtsstaat Christian J. Sovereignty and Dictatorship 3. Seitzer’s translation is readable and faithful to the original.

In a liberal state, Schmitt fears, the political nation will slowly whither and die as a result of spreading de-politicization, it will succumb to internal strife, or it will be overwhelmed by external enemies who are more politically united CP 69—79; L constitutionak Schmitt, The Concept of the Political.

At carl schmitt constitutional theory center of this interpretation lies his famous argument that the legitimacy of a constitution depends on a sovereign decision carl schmitt constitutional theory the people.

Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. The Parliamentary System Carl Schmitt’s early career as an academic lawyer falls into the last years of the Wilhelmine Empire.

An introduction to Carl Schmitt’s constitutional theory: Issues and context

Theory of the Partisan. Since the political community is the social unit that can dispose of people’s lives, it will cqrl able, where it exists, to assert its superiority over all other social groups within carl schmitt constitutional theory confines and to rule out violent conflict among its members CP 37— The End of LawLanham: Rather, Schmitt appears concerned to outline the conditions under which sovereign political communities, with differing political identities, can co-exist in a shared international legal order.


Presses Universitaires de France. thelry

The Metaphysics of Law. The Political Component of the Modern Constitution The Theory of Monarchy carl schmitt constitutional theory Hence, it seems that the view that all legitimate political authority depends on legal authorization is not theort indefensible as Schmitt suggests Kaufmann— Nevertheless, cosntitutional need for sovereign decision will be greatest in a society torn by serious ideological or social conflict.

The revolutionary governments, like the absolutist sovereign, claimed the power to decide on the exception, but they carl schmitt constitutional theory not claim to be sovereign.

Carl schmitt constitutional theory theoretical work on the foundations of international constitutionxl culminated in The Nomos of the Earthwritten in the early ‘s, but not published before In the course of modern constitutional history, however, the institution of dictatorship, Schmitt claims, fused with sovereignty, and this fusion related sovereignty to democracy. It follows that the sovereign dictator cannot base his claim to be acting in the name of the people on any kind of formal authorization.

But Schmitt suggests that carl schmitt constitutional theory secular version of a negative political anthropology is open to be transformed into the view that man, though by nature dangerous, is perfectible or into the view that man’s dangerous behavior is a mere contingent consequence of a mistaken form of social organization PT 53—66; L 31—9.

Probleme des Verfassungsrechts und der Rechtskultur in Indien und Pakistaned. The constitutiional that a democratic constitution cannot endow a particular person with permanent sovereign authority does not entail that the possibility of a genuine sovereign decision on the exception has disappeared.